The Supplement Paradox: What Happens When Everyone's Right (And Wrong)

After 30 years watching women navigate natural solutions, here's what the wellness industry isn't telling you about supplements

Of course you are confused about supplements. Supplements are an industry which wants you to buy more.

Art of Menopausing is a a space where we speak natural menopause. Consider upgrading to a paid subscription to reduce the overwhelm.

Maybe you're not sleeping as well as you used to. Your mood feels... off. Your energy isn't what it was. Nothing serious enough for a doctor's visit, but enough to make you wonder what's happening.

So you do what most of us do – turn to Google, join some Facebook groups, and start researching natural solutions.

"The journey from vague symptoms to a shopping cart full of supplements is shorter than you might think."

The journey usually goes something like this: late-night symptom searches lead to wellness blogs and Facebook groups, which lead to Amazon carts filled with supplements promising relief. Magnesium for sleep, ashwagandha for stress, omega 3's for hot flashes – the list grows longer as symptoms persist.

Here's the thing – I get it. I truly do.

When you're dealing with symptoms that feel too vague for a doctor but too disruptive to ignore, the world of natural supplements feels like a beacon of hope. The bottles promise gentle, natural relief. The reviews share stories of women finding their way back to themselves. And best of all, you can take control without waiting for things to get "bad enough" for medical intervention.

Natural doesn't automatically mean safe – or even effective.

But after three decades watching this scene play out – from behind the supplement counter to my Ayurvedic practice – I need to share something important: "natural" doesn't automatically mean "safe" or even "effective." In fact, some of the most common natural supplements recommended for menopause can cause more harm than good when used incorrectly or by the wrong person.

Why Women Turn to Natural Solutions

"Have you tried losing weight?" asked the doctor, barely glancing up from her computer. My client, Sarah sat there, her carefully documented list of symptoms – night sweats, heart palpitations, and anxiety – completely ignored. She'd waited three months for this appointment.

Two days later, she was doing what millions of women do: desperately researching natural menopause solutions online, comparing supplement reviews, and joining Facebook groups for answers.

The dismissal in the doctor's office becomes the determination to find answers elsewhere.

The Dismissal Dance

It usually starts with what I call "the dismissal dance." You know the steps: you share your symptoms, they're minimized or dismissed. Hot flashes? "That's just menopause." Mood changes? "It's hormonal." Fatigue? "Well, you're not twenty anymore." This dismissal isn't just frustrating – it's dangerous. It leaves women feeling unheard and desperate for alternatives, sometimes leading to self-prescribed supplement regimens that might not be appropriate for their unique situation.

The dismissal dance leads many women straight to the supplement aisle – but that's where the real story begins.

When Healthcare Isn't Actually Accessible

Then there's the practical reality: many women simply can't access conventional healthcare consistently.

Maybe it's the three-month wait for a specialist appointment. Or perhaps it's the cost – especially for those in the healthcare coverage gap.

Taking Back Control

Here's something we don't talk about enough: the deep human need for agency over our own health and bodies. After being told to "just deal with it" or offered one-size-fits-all solutions, the ability to walk into a store and choose your own treatment feels empowering.

Natural supplements seem to offer what conventional medicine often doesn't: options, control, and hope.

The Promise of "Natural"

Let's be honest – we've all been influenced by the compelling story that "natural" equals "better." It's a narrative that resonates especially deeply during menopause, when many women are questioning conventional hormone therapy and seeking gentler alternatives. It taps into a genuine desire to work with our bodies rather than in spite of them.

The word 'natural' promises what we desperately want: gentle healing without side effects. But that promise needs a closer look."

Beyond the Natural Health Halo

Understanding these drives to seek natural solutions is crucial - but so is understanding the science behind what we're actually putting in our bodies. Let's look at two of the most commonly recommended supplements to understand why "natural" solutions require just as much careful consideration as conventional ones.

The Magnesium Story: Not As Simple As "Just Take a Different Kind"

Let's talk about magnesium - if there was a popularity contest for menopause supplements, magnesium would win by a landslide.

Pop into any menopause forum and you'll find magnesium prescribed for everything. But here's what those enthusiastic posts aren't telling you..."

Why Everyone's Obsessed With Magnesium

Let's talk about the supplement that's become the unofficial queen of menopause relief. If there was a popularity contest for menopause supplements, magnesium would win by a landslide. Pop into any menopause forum and you'll find it prescribed for everything from sleepless nights to cranky muscles to heart palpitations.

The fascinating thing is – the hype isn't entirely misplaced. Your body uses this mighty mineral in over 300 enzymatic processes. From muscle function to nervous system regulation, proper sleep to mood stability – magnesium plays a crucial role in how your body navigates menopause.

The Hidden Story of Our Food Supply

But here's where things get interesting (and a bit depressing).

When people say, "Our ancestors got enough magnesium from food," they're both right and wrong. Yes, humans evolved getting sufficient magnesium from their food supply. But – and this is crucial – that food supply looked nothing like what's on your plate today, even if you're shopping at the fancy organic market.

"A carrot today contains significantly less magnesium than a carrot from 1950. This isn't about organic versus conventional – it's about how our entire food system has changed."

The Ayurvedic Perspective on Today’s Food

The Ayurvedic perspective considers another fascinating layer: prāna, or the vital life force energy in our food.

Think about the journey most produce takes to reach our plates – often traveling across countries or continents. This means fruits and vegetables need to be harvested early, before they've developed their full nutrient profile through natural ripening. And during those long journeys from farm to table, food gradually loses its prāna or qi.

Many women turn to supplements to bridge the nutritional gap. It's a logical step – if we can't get enough magnesium from food, surely supplementation is the answer? But after years of working in both natural products retail and Ayurvedic practice, I've learned it's not quite that straightforward.

Form Matters: The Rock in Your Bottle

Let's start with a simple truth – magnesium is a mineral, literally derived from the earth. When we're talking about supplements, we're essentially talking about different ways of making rock digestible. This might sound strange, but it helps explain why form is so crucial for absorption.

"That magnesium supplement?

It's basically rock that they're trying to make digestible.”

Here's what you need to know:

• The common magnesium oxide supplements you'll find on most shelves have an absorption rate of only about 4%. The remaining 96% passes through your digestive system, often causing uncomfortable digestive issues.

• Magnesium citrate pairs the mineral with citric acid, making it more easily recognized by your body. While it absorbs better than oxide, its strong osmotic effect means it can still trigger digestive changes.

• Magnesium glycinate, where the mineral is bound to the amino acid glycine, tends to be gentler on digestion and may support both sleep and nerve function.

• Magnesium malate combines magnesium with malic acid, which your cells naturally produce. This form is particularly interesting for energy production and muscle function.

Individual Differences: Your Body's Unique Response

Just as Ayurveda recognizes different doṣas, our bodies have different needs and absorption capabilities. What works for your best friend might turn your digestive system into a war zone.

The Body's Warning Signs

Here's something I've noticed repeatedly: your body speaks up when a supplement isn't right. But we've been conditioned to dismiss these signals because we believe anything natural must be safe and healthy.

Digestive changes, headaches, energy crashes – these are real responses from your body, not minor inconveniences to push through. When we operate under the belief that "natural equals safe," we might ignore clear signs that a supplement isn't working for us, or worse, is creating new problems.

Your body isn't being difficult when it rejects a supplement – it's being brilliantly honest."

A More Nuanced Approach

After thirty years in this field, here's what I've learned about magnesium:

• Testing Matters: Most magnesium tests are about as useful as a chocolate teapot because they measure blood levels, not cellular levels where magnesium actually does its work.

• Food First: Yes, our soil is depleted, but focusing on magnesium-rich foods along with proper digestion (agni for the win!) often works better than supplements alone.

• Absorption is Key: Ayurveda teaches us that it's not just what you take, but how well your body can use it. Factors like stress, digestive fire, and even the time of day can affect how well you absorb magnesium.

Finding Your Balance

Rather than asking "Should I take magnesium?" try asking:

• How's my digestion really doing?

• What form of magnesium might work best for my body type and symptoms?

• What other factors might be affecting my mineral absorption?

• Am I taking other supplements or medications that might be playing bouncer to my magnesium?

This brings us to another "natural" solution that's taken the menopause world by storm – ashwagandha. I could go on and on about ashwaganda and every herb originally from Ayurveda which has become “newly discovered miracle cure super food”. But that's a whole other story of how ancient wisdom got lost in modern marketing, sigh.

The Ashwagandha Paradox: When Ancient Medicine Meets Modern Marketing

"It's amazing! It helped my friend with anxiety, sleep and hot flashes, but it made mine so much worse!"

Ah, the Ashwagandha Paradox in action. Maria's experience perfectly captures what happens when an ancient herb collides head-on with modern marketing. How can the same "natural" herb be both miraculous and problematic? Grab your chai – let's talk about what those perky wellness influencers aren't telling you about this ancient medicine.

The same herb that's a miracle for your friend might be your worst nightmare. Here's why that's perfectly normal."

The Adaptogen Celebrity

Ashwagandha has become the Kardashian of the supplement world – it's everywhere, promising everything. Stress? Ashwagandha. Anxiety? Ashwagandha. Hot flashes, insomnia, fatigue, brain fog? Ashwagandha, ashwagandha, ashwagandha!

And here's the thing – technically, none of these claims are entirely wrong. This herb has been used in Ayurvedic medicine for thousands of years for many of these issues.

But here's what those glossy marketing materials (and that enthusiastic yoga teacher who's suddenly selling supplements) don't tell you: in traditional Ayurvedic medicine, ashwagandha was never given to everyone. It was prescribed selectively, based on a person's constitution (prakṛti), current condition (vikṛti), and specific imbalances.

It's like casting for a play – not everyone gets the leading role, no matter how talented they are."

The Heating Dilemma

Picture this scene from my supplement department days: A woman comes in, fanning herself, looking distinctly unhappy. "My hot flashes and sleeping is worse than ever since starting ashwagandha. But it's natural! How can it make things worse?"

Well, honey, let me tell you about virya (heating energy). In Ayurvedic terms, ashwagandha can increase pitta doṣha. For women already experiencing hot flashes and night sweats (classic pitta imbalance!), adding more heat to the system is like throwing gasoline on a fire and wondering why things got hotter. Natural? Yes. Helpful? About as helpful as wearing a wool sweater in a sauna.

"Adding ashwagandha to hot flashes is like wearing a wool sweater in a sauna – natural, but not exactly helpful."

When Strength Becomes Weakness

Another classic scene: Some women taking ashwagandha for exhaustion only to end up feeling wired, anxious, and even more tired. The modern marketing narrative tells us adaptogens help us "adapt to stress." What it doesn't tell us is that not all stress is created equal, and not all bodies respond to strengthening herbs the same way.

Think of it this way: if you're exhausted because you've been pushing too hard for too long (I see you, superwoman), taking an herb that helps you push even harder might not be the answer. Sometimes, what we interpret as resilience in action is actually our body screaming "ENOUGH ALREADY!"

The Quality Question

Here's something else they don't put on those pretty Instagram posts: not all ashwagandha is created equal. Traditional preparation methods involved specific parts of the plant, harvested at particular times, processed in particular ways. Modern manufacturing often skips these crucial steps faster than a teenager skips breakfast.

Who Should (and Shouldn't) Take Ashwagandha

Based on both traditional wisdom and clinical experience, here's your cheat sheet:

Might Be Helpful For:

• Vata types running on anxiety and racing thoughts

• Women experiencing primarily cold symptoms during menopause

• Those with depleted tissue strength (dhatu kshaya)

Exercise Caution If You Have:

• Significant hot flashes or night sweats (unless you enjoy feeling like a human torch)

• High pitta conditions (acid reflux, skin inflammation, irritability)

• Autoimmune conditions (it can stimulate the immune system)

• Hyperthyroidism (it may increase thyroid hormone levels)

Sometimes the most powerful medicine isn't about adding something new, but about understanding what our bodies are truly asking for."

Kapha Folks - It's Complicated

Here's where it gets interesting. While ashwagandha's warming energy might help with kapha's typical coldness, its building quality (that's what makes it great for strengthening) could contribute to weight gain. It's like choosing between wearing a sweater or carrying a space heater - both warm you up, but one adds extra baggage. Work with a practitioner to weigh the trade-offs for your specific situation.

The Wiser Way Forward

Instead of asking "Should I take ashwagandha?" consider these questions:

• Are my symptoms more about feeling cold and depleted, or am I radiating heat?

• How do I typically react to warming substances?

• What's really driving my stress and fatigue?

• Am I looking for a quick fix to a deeper issue?

A Personal Note

I'll never forget the customer who came in weekly for months, trying every adaptogenic herb we sold, determined to find her magic bullet. Nothing helped until she finally talked to me when Ayurveda was a side gig. I helped her understand that her body wasn't asking for more strength – it was asking for rest, nourishment, and a different way of living and that there was a better herb for her constitution.

Your body's resistance to a supplement isn't a failure – it's valuable information about what you really need."

And perhaps that's the biggest paradox of all: sometimes the most powerful medicine isn't about adding something new, but about understanding what our bodies are truly asking for. Which brings us to an even bigger conversation about supplements in general...

The Supplementation Paradox: Why More Isn't Better

I watched a woman at the coop methodically filling her basket: calcium for bones, magnesium for sleep, vitamin D for mood, ashwagandha for stress, black cohosh for hot flashes... By the time she reached the counter, she had twelve different supplements. "I'm determined to do menopause naturally," she declared. And there I stood, biting my tongue so hard I probably needed a supplement for it.

At what point does 'natural' supplementation become as artificial as the conventional treatments we're trying to avoid?"

The irony runs deep. In our quest to avoid pharmaceutical medications, we've simply swapped one pill-for-every-symptom mindset for another. We've traded prescriptions for supplements while keeping the same reductionist thinking that got us here in the first place. It's like changing the actors but keeping the same problematic script.

Here's what I've learned watching thousands of women navigate their health: Menopausal symptoms aren't your enemy. Every hot flash, every sleepless night, every mood swing is your body trying to tell you something important. When we rush to silence these messages with supplements, we miss the whole conversation. It's like putting your fingers in your ears and humming while your best friend tries to tell you something crucial.

The Supplement Spiral

Consider this all-too-familiar scene from my practice:

• A woman takes magnesium for sleep

• The magnesium throws her digestion into chaos

• She adds digestive enzymes

• Those create acid reflux

• She reaches for herbs to calm the reflux And down the rabbit hole we go...

"You're not what you eat – you're what you can digest, absorb, assimilate, and eliminate."

In Ayurveda, there's a fundamental truth: You're not what you take – you're what you can digest, absorb, assimilate, and eliminate. (Sorry, but that $75 bottle of supplements isn't doing much if it's just creating expensive pee.) This is where our supplement obsession breaks down:

• Multiple supplements overwhelm digestive capacity (agni) at every level

• Weakened digestion leads to poor absorption

• Undigested supplements create toxic buildup (ama)

• Poor assimilation means tissues aren't getting what they need

• The body gets weaker trying to process and eliminate the excess

• We add more supplements to fix problems caused by poor assimilation

• And the cycle continues...

The Hidden Costs

The cost isn't just financial (though I've seen monthly supplement bills that would make a luxury car payment look reasonable). It's the mental load of complex schedules, the stress of endless research, the anxiety of never doing "enough," and most importantly – the burden on your body's intelligence.

The women who navigate menopause most gracefully often take fewer supplements, not more. Plot twist, right?"

Here's what fascinates me: The women who navigate menopause most gracefully often take fewer supplements, not more. They focus on:

• Deep nourishment through food (yes, actual food!)

• Supporting digestive strength

• Addressing root causes through lifestyle

• Using specific supplements strategically, not scattershot

Making Peace with Supplements: Developing Your Individual Strategy

"I feel like I'm doing everything right," my client sighed, sliding a three-page supplement diary across my desk during her initial Ayurvedic consultation. Each page meticulously documented what she took, when she took it, and what happened. Her frustration was palpable – and familiar.

Doing 'everything right' according to general advice often means doing everything wrong for your unique body.

Redefining "Natural" Healing Through Ayurveda

Let's pause for a moment. What if I told you that true natural healing has little to do with finding the perfect supplement combination? It's really about understanding three fundamental aspects of your body's intelligence:

1. Your Unique Blueprint

• Your doṣha (fundamental constitution)

• Your agni (digestive fire)

• Your current āma (toxin) levels

2. Your Natural Rhythms

• Your dinacharya (daily routines)

• Your seasonal shifts

• Your patterns of eating, sleeping, and movement

3. Your Body's Language

• Symptoms are messages, not enemies

• Breaking free from the "suppress and push through" cycle

• Creating a sustainable way to listen to your body

Your Practical Path Forward

Before reaching for another supplement, try this for two weeks:

Symptom Mapping and Tracking

• Create a list of your symptoms

• Choose your primary focus symptom

• Note patterns in other symptoms

• Record when symptoms shift

• Document triggers (food, activities, thoughts)

• Map your daily rhythm patterns

• Notice how your body responds to different inputs

"Your body's wisdom is worth more than a thousand supplement reviews."

Finding Support

Remember this: supplements are like scaffolding – temporary support structures, not permanent solutions. True healing emerges from understanding and working with your body's innate wisdom, especially when guided by Ayurvedic principles of harmony for your unique constitution.

The word "supplement" literally means "in addition to" - not instead of your body's natural healing capacity. As you navigate your own supplement journey, remember that your body's resistance isn't a failure – it's valuable information about what you really need.

Remember: the word "supplement" literally means "in addition to" - not instead of your body's natural healing capacity. True healing emerges from understanding and working with your body's innate wisdom, guided by Ayurvedic principles of balance and your unique constitution.

Ready to explore an Ayurvedic approach to menopause? Consider becoming a paid subscriber for down to keep things natural and keep this newsletter alive.

Whether through our growing community of wise women or connecting one-on-one, Thanks for joining me here as I try to make sense of it all  (and yeah, occasional cursing - because menopause keeps it real).